summary

Stop The Talking In Shul - Rabbi Paysach Krohn on Stop the Talking in Shul Tosfos Yom Tov

Thumbnail of the video “Stop The Talking In Shul - Rabbi Paysach Krohn on Stop the Talking in Shul Tosfos Yom Tov”
Community upload. AI output has not been independently verified.

Short Summary

Main recommendation: Do not talk during davening in shul, because tefillah is a continuous thought process and conversation with Hashem that interruptions disrupt. The Taz Yom Tov's special prayer for those who refrain from speaking in shul confers blessings on them in this world and the next. The speaker presents this as a guard against the disgrace of desecrating a shul, which he calls a mikdash me'at.

Key Points

  • The Taz Yom Tov's tefillah for those who refrain from talking in shul promises blessings, including children who will live long and bring nachas.
  • The Maharal's teaching frames tefillah as a thought process and conversation between the individual and Hashem, which talking interrupts.
  • According to the speaker, the Taz Yom Tov wrote a prayer after the 1648–1649 Tach v'Tat massacres, in which he asked in a dream-question (she'eilas chalom) why Jews suffered, and was answered that lackadaisical conduct and talking during davening in shul was a cause.
  • The word "shul" is explained by the speaker as an acronym-style reminder of gates of righteousness, thanks, and salvation, and shul is a place to give thanks to Hashem, which should not be interrupted.
  • The Taz Yom Tov divided the Orchos Chaim into seven daily portions, and the speaker says the Tuesday portion includes a warning not to engage in idle talk in shul.

Details Worth Noting

  • Concrete instructions: Refrain from talking during davening in shul. Do not start conversations with others during prayer, and do not interrupt others' conversations with Hashem. Keep your tefillah focused and connected, treating the shul as a place of thanks and holiness. The speaker also recommends saying the Taz Yom Tov's special tefillah for those who refrain from speaking in shul, and following the daily Orchos Chaim portion for the day of the week, with the Tuesday portion warning against idle talk in shul.
  • The Taz Yom Tov was born after his father died, was raised by his grandfather, and was given the additional names Gershon and Shaul, which most people do not know.
  • He was arrested in 1629 after his enemies accused him to the Christian government, was held in solitary confinement in Vienna, and the episode was later written about in the sefer Megillas Ahav.
  • The speaker says he visits the Taz Yom Tov's grave in Krakow's Remuh Cemetery on tours to Poland, where other gedolim like the Rema, Maharam Shiff, and Maharsha are also buried.
  • The speaker notes the video was recorded on a Tuesday, which he uses to tie the Orchos Chaim portion to that day.

Bottom Line

Avoiding talk during davening is presented as a way to protect the holiness of tefillah and the shul, and the speaker ties this to the Taz Yom Tov's blessings and to a historical warning against lackadaisical conduct.

Facts

  1. According to Rabbi Paysach Krohn, Rabbi Yom Tov Lipman Heller was born after his father died.

    3:50